FBD Group FBD Group FBD Group FBD Group

FBD Statement

To Joint Committee on Finance, Public Expenditure and Reform, and Taoiseach.

FBD is the local Irish insurer.  We are part of and embedded in Irish  communities, with branches located in cities and towns throughout the country.  Insuring farms and small businesses, is our business.  They are critically important to us and represent 85% of our turnover, in premium terms. 

It is our job to be there when things go wrong.  We in FBD have a proud and long tradition, spanning more than 50 years, of paying claims and looking after our customers when things go wrong. 

From 2014- 2016 FBD was making a loss.  It is in our customers’ interest that we have stabilised and returned to making a profit.  To stand by our customers and pay our claims, we must be stable and profitable.  We have stabilised through taking a raft measures, including charging more to our customers. 

The cost of insurance is too high. It is affecting our customers’ ability to do business and that affects us.  While a lot has happened in the attempt to address the cost of insurance but not enough has changed. 

With the permission of this Committee, I would like to share with you FBD’s insights into why this is the case and what we believe needs to change 

Firstly, I’d like to summarise what is causing the high cost of insurance, at its essence:  -we are having too many claims and those claims are costing too much.

In too many claims:

Those claims are costing too much:

To address the root cause of high cost insurance, all roads lead to our adversarial legal system.

The legal system dictates the level of award; it sets the ‘market price’ that determines the level of all awards both in-court and out-of court. This system creates a vicious cycle: high pay-outs with no downside encourage claimants; and high legal fees encourage certain solicitors and barristers to take and make the case.

The legal system is difficult to reform and resistant to change.  This is why we have little progress on lowering legal costs.  There is little motivation to change the system; practitioners have little to gain and much to lose.  I would go further and say I believe:

Litigation is always expensive. Allow me to share with you how costs spiral as a consequence of this system.

Take as an example a ‘soft tissue injury’ from a low impact collision; meaning there was little or no damage to the car; the occupant has a sore neck; remembering ‘soft-tissue injuries’ comprise about 80% of ourinjury costs; and it is the kind of injury that some other jurisdictions do not recognise or at least pay little or nothing for.

Normally it will take at least 3 years and up to 5 years, (or more), from the date of the accident until the case is heard in court.  Time drives award levels and incurs legal costs.

The Injuries Board assess the injury 12-18 months after the accident based on a medical report that gives a 6 month prognosis.  But the majority of claimants will report pain right up to their day in court, 3 to 5 years later.   The judge will make an award based on 3-5 years of pain. 

The key insight is that, the level of award is based on the length of time a claimant is complaining of pain, as opposed to the amount of pain they actually feel. Compensation is more a function of time than of suffering.

Court awards, determined later than the Injuries Board, are higher.  Costs are significantly higher.  There is major incentive to bring the claim to litigation; to this legal system involving high pay-outs and high costs. 

Claimants win; but Lawyers also win, taking approximately. 40% of the settlement in costs;

Insurance customers and businesses lose; society loses.

FBD has publically stated what we believe must be prioritised; FBD’s key recommendations remain outstanding or remain a work-in-progress:

In a nutshell, we need to build momentum and drive home meaningful reform of the legal system.

Oireachtas engagement in relation to insurance costs for small and medium-sized businesses

In conclusion

FBD’s CEO, Fiona Muldoon, has said:

“Irish society can either have high injury awards or cheap insurance.  We cannot have both.” 

As the legislature, you have the sole ability to help deliver what is to the greater benefit, for most in our society.